Tail docking (caudectomy) and ear cropping (otectomy) in dogs are among the most heavily criticized practices in the field of animal welfare. What exactly do these procedures entail, and why do they generate so much controversy? This article examines the origins of these mutilations, their consequences for dogs, and the legal framework that governs them today.
What is tail docking in dogs?
The term caudectomy comes from the Latin cauda ("tail") and the Greek ektomē ("removal"). It refers to the partial or total amputation of a dog's tail. This practice is often associated with otectomy , which involves cropping the ears, and is part of a set of procedures long considered traditional.
Origin of tail and ear cropping
These practices date back several centuries. Originally, they mainly concerned hunting or fighting dogs. The aim was to limit the risk of injury during confrontations or in difficult environments.
Nowadays, these interventions are mostly carried out for aesthetic reasons, a motivation that is widely questioned in light of animal welfare.
How do these interventions take place?
Like any surgical procedure, ear or tail cropping should be performed under anesthesia. However, this is not always the case in some countries where regulations are less strict.
The techniques vary depending on the part of the body involved:
-
Tail : The veterinarian makes an incision in the skin around the base of the tail and cuts the tissue between two vertebrae.
-
Ears : A template is used to guide the cutting. The ears are held in a specific device before the ends are removed with a scalpel.
In both situations, nerves and blood vessels are affected, which can lead to persistent pain for several weeks after the procedure.
At what age are these practices carried out?
Tail docking is usually performed very early, often around seven weeks of age. In an adult dog, this operation is much less common, as it involves more complex surgery and an increased risk of complications.
Why do we cut off dogs' tails and ears?
Several arguments are put forward to justify these practices. Aside from medical cases, the main motivation remains aesthetics. Some breeders believe that a dog with a docked tail or cropped ears conforms more closely to historical standards or to a more "balanced" appearance.
Injury prevention is also sometimes cited, particularly for hunting or working dogs, the idea being that shortened limbs are less likely to catch on vegetation.
Which breeds are most affected?
Tail docking and ear cropping are more frequently observed in certain breeds, including:
-
the Doberman,
-
the American Staffordshire Terrier,
-
the Boxer,
-
the Great Dane,
-
the Pinscher,
-
the American Pit Bull Terrier,
-
the Schnauzer.
Many of these breeds are historically associated with so-called "fighting" dogs.
Why are these practices so controversial?
Like brachycephaly, ear and tail cropping has generated much criticism related to animal welfare.
Impaired communication
In dogs, the tail and ears play a fundamental role in communication. They allow the dog to express emotions, send signals to other dogs, and interact with humans.
A dog deprived of these means of expression may experience relational difficulties, generating misunderstandings, tensions, or even behavioral problems such as aggression.
Health risks
All surgical procedures carry risks: infections, bleeding, or wound healing problems. In addition, there are more subtle complications, such as phantom limb pain, which can persist throughout the dog's life.
Disrupted coordination
The tail also plays a role in a dog's balance. It acts as a counterbalance when the dog runs, jumps, or changes direction abruptly. Its absence can impair coordination and make certain sporting activities, such as agility, more difficult.
Are tail docking and ear cropping permitted in France?
French law prohibits any mutilation not medically justified. The Rural Code specifies that it is forbidden to remove sensitive parts of an animal's body without therapeutic necessity. Therefore, cuts performed for aesthetic or traditional purposes are illegal.
What about dogs that have already been mutilated?
It remains legal to own, sell, or import a dog whose tail or ears have been cropped, provided the procedure was performed in a country where it is permitted. However, these dogs cannot participate in official shows or competitions in France if the mutilation is purely cosmetic.
International situation
In most European countries, these practices are now prohibited. However, some owners or breeders circumvent the law by traveling to countries where they remain legal, such as Russia, the United States, or certain regions of Latin America. This "harvesting tourism" is strongly condemned by animal protection organizations.
In what cases is tail docking still permitted?
In France, tail docking is only permitted in very specific situations:
-
Medical reasons : when a veterinarian deems amputation essential for the dog's health (tumor, necrosis, serious injury). The procedure must then be performed under anesthesia and in a strictly veterinary setting.
-
Hunting dogs : an exception exists for certain breeds intended for hunting. A decree authorizes tail docking in the first few days of life (before 5 days), performed by a veterinarian, solely to prevent injuries. The owner must be able to prove the dog's use for hunting and the absence of any medical contraindication.
What is the cost of a tail docking?
When performed for medical reasons, the price of a tail docking varies according to several factors: the veterinary clinic, the age of the dog, and the necessary post-operative care.